top of page
  • Royal Recovery, LLC

Car Trouble? Could It Be the Starter?

When you're experiencing car trouble, diagnosing the issue can be a challenge. At Royal Recovery, our expertise in roadside assistance means we can help you understand the potential causes, such as a dying starter.

If your car sounds like it's struggling to start, it could be the starter. A dying car starter might produce a clicking noise, a grinding sound, or a series of rapid clicks. These noises indicate that the starter motor is failing, or the electrical connection is weak.

Don't worry; we have plenty more information to share that will help you identify and address starter-related issues. Keep reading to learn more!

Common Symptoms of a Failing Starter

A failing starter often presents several telltale symptoms that, when recognized early, can help prevent further damage or being stranded. One of the most common signs is a clicking sound when you turn the ignition key, which is typically caused by a weak electrical connection or a failing solenoid. A solenoid is an electromagnetic device that helps to control the flow of current in your vehicle. Another symptom is a grinding noise, like the sound you hear when you accidentally try to start the car while it's already running. This grinding occurs when the starter gear is not properly engaging with the engine's flywheel.

Additionally, a whirring sound without any engine cranking might indicate a freewheeling starter, which means the starter motor is spinning without engaging the flywheel.

It's important to recognize that a dying starter isn't the only reason your car might struggle to start. Issues such as a weak battery, poor electrical connections, or a faulty ignition switch can also cause similar symptoms. However, if you're experiencing a combination of these symptoms, such as clicking or grinding noises, slow engine cranking, and intermittent failure to start, it's more likely that the starter is the culprit. These issues can become more pronounced in cold weather, when the starter has to work harder to turn over the engine.

Causes of a Dying Car Starter

There are several factors that can lead to a dying car starter. One of the primary causes is normal wear and tear, as the starter motor contains moving parts that can wear out over time. This is especially true for the brushes inside the starter motor, which are responsible for maintaining electrical contact with the spinning armature. As the brushes wear down, the starter's performance can deteriorate, leading to the characteristic symptoms of a failing starter. The solenoid, which engages the starter motor with the engine's flywheel, can also wear out, causing the starter to malfunction.

Another cause of a dying car starter is exposure to extreme heat. Elevated temperatures can cause the starter's internal components to expand, potentially leading to reduced performance or even failure. This is particularly relevant for vehicles with exhaust systems located near the starter, as the heat generated by the exhaust can significantly increase the starter's operating temperature. In some cases, installing a heat shield or relocating the starter can help mitigate this issue.

Poor electrical connections are another common reason for a failing starter. Corrosion, loose terminals, or frayed wiring can lead to insufficient current reaching the starter motor, causing it to struggle to engage or disengage properly. Over time, these electrical issues can cause excessive wear on the starter, leading to its failure. Regular inspection and maintenance of your vehicle's electrical connections can help prolong the life of your starter and prevent unexpected breakdowns.

How to Test Your Starter at Home

Testing your starter at home can help you determine whether it's the cause of your car's starting issues. First, ensure your car battery is fully charged and in good condition, as a weak battery can mimic starter problems. Check the battery's voltage using a multimeter by connecting the red lead of the multimeter to the positive terminal on the starter motor and the black lead to the negative terminal, and the black lead to a good ground on the engine. a healthy battery should read around 12.6 volts. Anything under 12 means the battery will not function properly. If you don’t own a multimeter, most auto-part stores can test your battery for free. Next, inspect the battery terminals and the connections to the starter motor for corrosion or looseness. If everything seems fine, proceed with the starter test.

The best at-home method to test the starter is by performing a "bench test." This test requires removing the starter from the vehicle and connecting it to a separate battery using jumper cables. Ensure you follow the appropriate procedure for your vehicle when removing the starter. Once the starter is removed, connect the positive jumper cable to the starter's positive terminal and the negative cable to the starter casing. Touch the other ends of the jumper cables to the corresponding terminals on a fully charged battery. If the starter motor engages and spins without issue, it is functioning correctly. If it fails to engage or struggles to spin, it's a sign that the starter is faulty and may need repair or replacement. Remember, working with electrical systems can be dangerous; if you're not confident in your abilities, it's best to seek professional help.

When to Seek Professional Help

While it's possible to diagnose and test a starter at home, there are situations when seeking professional help is the best course of action. If you've performed the tests mentioned above and still can't determine the cause of your car's starting issues, it's time to consult a professional mechanic. If you're not confident in your abilities to safely perform these tests or lack the necessary tools, it's better to leave the job to the experts. Automotive professionals have access to specialized diagnostic equipment, tools, in-depth knowledge, and experience that can quickly identify and fix the problem.

Another reason to seek professional help is if the starter motor needs replacement. Replacing a starter can be a complex and labor-intensive process, depending on your vehicle's make and model. While some cars have easily accessible starters, others may require the removal of additional components or even lifting the engine. In these cases, attempting to replace the starter yourself without proper tools and expertise can lead to damage or injury. A professional mechanic will have the necessary experience and equipment to replace the starter motor safely and efficiently.

Finally, seeking professional help is essential when you suspect other issues may be contributing to your car's starting problems. As previously mentioned, a weak battery, poor electrical connections, or a faulty ignition switch can also cause similar symptoms to a failing starter. A skilled mechanic can perform a thorough inspection of your vehicle, identify the root cause of the issue, and recommend the most appropriate course of action. By seeking professional assistance, you can save time, prevent further damage, and ensure your vehicle's reliability and safety.

The Cost of Replacing a Car Starter

The cost of replacing a car starter can vary widely depending on several factors, such as the make, model and age of your vehicle, the type of starter required, and the labor rates at the repair shop.

On average, you can expect to pay anywhere between $300 and $600 for a starter replacement. This includes the cost of the new starter itself, which typically ranges from $50 to $300, and the labor fees, which can be anywhere from $200 to $300 or more, depending on the complexity of the job. Keep in mind that these are general estimates, and the actual cost may differ based on your specific situation.

It’s a good idea to call around and get quotes from different mechanic shops when replacing your car's starter to ensure you receive the best service at a fair price. Comparing quotes allows you to gauge the market rates and avoid overpaying for the service. Additionally, researching reviews and asking questions about each shop can help you determine their reputation, expertise, and customer service quality. This ensures that you not only get the best value for your money but also entrust your vehicle to a reliable professional who will complete the job efficiently and effectively. When seeking quotes, don't forget to ask about the type of starter they recommend (new, rebuilt, or remanufactured), as this can impact both the cost and long-term reliability of the replacement.

In addition to the cost of parts and labor, there are other factors to consider when replacing a car starter. For instance, if the starter is difficult to access, it may require additional time and labor to remove and reinstall other components, which can increase the overall cost. If you choose to use a rebuilt or remanufactured starter, you may save money on the parts cost, but the long-term reliability could be compromised. It's essential to weigh these factors when deciding on a starter replacement and to consult a trusted professional mechanic for guidance on the best options for your vehicle. By doing your due diligence, you can make an informed decision that benefits both your vehicle and your wallet.

Preventative Maintenance for a Longer-Lasting Starter

Preventative maintenance is crucial for ensuring a longer-lasting starter and avoiding unexpected breakdowns. One of the key factors in maintaining your starter's longevity is keeping your car's battery in good condition, as a weak or failing battery can put additional strain on the starter motor.

Regularly inspect your battery for corrosion, clean the terminals, and check its voltage to ensure it remains at an optimal level. Make sure all electrical connections between the battery, starter, and alternator are clean, tight, and free from corrosion. This will help maintain proper electrical flow and reduce the stress on the starter motor.

Another aspect of preventative maintenance involves being mindful of how you operate your vehicle. Avoid turning the ignition key for extended periods when starting the engine, as this can cause excessive wear on the starter motor. Typically, cranking the engine for no more than 10 seconds at a time is recommended. If the engine doesn't start within that time, wait for a few seconds before trying again.

Be cautious not to accidentally engage the starter while the engine is running, as this can result in damage to the starter gear and the engine's flywheel. By practicing these habits and staying on top of routine maintenance, you can significantly extend the life of your starter and reduce the risk of encountering starter-related issues.


A struggling car starter can be a frustrating and inconvenient issue for any driver. However, by being aware of the common symptoms and causes of a failing starter, you can take steps to address the problem before it becomes a major headache. With the help of our guide, you can test your starter at home, learn when to seek professional assistance, and even take preventative measures to extend the life of your starter. And if you do find yourself stranded on the side of the road due to starter issues or other car troubles, remember that Royal Recovery is always there to provide reliable roadside assistance when you need it most.

Royal Recovery is your go-to source for comprehensive roadside assistance services in Artesia, with a team of experienced professionals who are dedicated to helping you get back on the road quickly and safely. Our wide range of services includes battery jumpstarts, tire changes, fuel delivery, lockout assistance, and towing, ensuring that we can address any roadside issue you may encounter. Visit our website or contact us today and let us be your trusted partner in keeping you safe and secure on the road.

1 view0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page